A good mortgage rate is one that sits at or below the current market average for your loan type, credit score, down payment, and term, and that stays competitive once points and fees are counted in the APR. A headline number can’t tell you that, because the same 6% can be a strong quote for one borrower and a weak one for another. What works is a method: start from an official benchmark, adjust for your profile, then compare offers by total cost.
I run Shop Mortgage Rates by Duane Buziak on the idea that you shouldn’t guess your rate, you should shop it. Every figure below that isn’t sourced to an agency is an illustration with its math shown, so you can swap in your own numbers.
Duane Buziak, NMLS #1110647
Benchmarking a Rate: Today’s Market Average Is Your Starting Line
The most useful public benchmark is the Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey (PMMS), published weekly with average rates for 30-year and 15-year fixed loans. Open that page, note the latest figure and its publication date, and write both next to your quote. I don’t print a number here because it would be stale within days. Whatever you find is an “as of” figure for that week, nothing more.
The PMMS describes a typical well-qualified borrower. If your quote is within a reasonable distance of it and your profile is typical, you’re in the zone. If your profile is stronger or weaker, your quote should land below or above it, and the next section explains by how much it should move.
Why an advertised rate is not a benchmark
Advertised rates frequently assume a high credit score, a large down payment, and paid discount points, and they apply to a specific lock period. The CFPB’s guidance on shopping for a mortgage tells you to collect multiple offers on the same day and compare them on equal terms, which is exactly what a headline rate prevents.
Two quotes, one $400,000 loan
Suppose, as an illustration, a 30-year fixed loan of $400,000. Quote A is 6.00% with 1.5 points ($6,000 upfront). Quote B is 6.25% with no points. The formula is the standard payment formula, M = P × r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)^−n), with r the monthly rate and n = 360.
- Quote A payment: $2,398.20. Quote B payment: $2,462.87. Monthly difference: $64.67.
- 3 years (36 months): savings of $2,328 against $6,000 paid, so A is behind by about $3,672.
- 7 years (84 months): savings of $5,432, so A is still behind by about $568.
- 15 years (180 months): savings of $11,641, so A is ahead by about $5,641.
This ignores the small extra principal paydown on A and any return you could earn on the $6,000, so treat it as a simplified model. The lower rate is the cheaper loan only if you keep it past roughly month 93.
What Moves Your Personal Rate Above or Below the Average
Pricing is built from a base rate plus adjustments. These are the levers that matter most:
- Credit score tier: higher tiers price better, and the breaks fall at set score bands.
- Loan-to-value (LTV): a larger down payment lowers LTV and usually lowers the rate or the cost of mortgage insurance.
- Loan type: conventional, FHA, VA, USDA, jumbo, and physician/doctor loans each price off different investor demand and insurance structures.
- Occupancy: primary homes price better than second homes and investment properties.
- Term: 15-year loans typically carry lower rates than 30-year loans, with much higher payments.
On conventional loans, many of these adjustments follow Fannie Mae’s loan-level price adjustments. The matrix is published on the Fannie Mae Single-Family site and is revised periodically, so I won’t quote specific adjustments here. Check the current version before relying on any secondhand figure.
Why program rates differ from real cost
FHA and VA rates can sit below conventional rates for the same borrower, but that doesn’t make them cheaper by default. FHA loans carry upfront and annual mortgage insurance premiums (see HUD for current premium schedules), and most VA purchase loans carry a funding fee unless you’re exempt (see VA.gov for current percentages). Both change the real cost, which is why the APR and total payment matter more than the rate.
For VA borrowers, I pull your Certificate of Eligibility electronically with your SSN and date of birth. If you’ve used entitlement before, second-tier (bonus) entitlement applies: take the county loan limit times 25% for the maximum guarantee, subtract the entitlement already in use, and multiply the remainder by four to find the zero-down purchase limit.
The lowest rate isn’t automatically the right loan. What you want is the lowest-cost loan for your situation, measured over the time you’ll realistically hold it.
To see personalized pricing, I offer a soft credit pull mortgage pre-approval. It works as a no credit hit mortgage application, so you can see where your profile lands against the benchmark before anything touches your score.
Rate vs. APR vs. Total Cost: Reading a Loan Estimate
Five terms drive the comparison:
- Interest rate: the cost of borrowing the principal, which sets your P&I payment.
- APR: the yearly cost including certain finance charges such as points and some lender fees. It does not include property taxes or homeowners insurance, and it assumes you keep the loan for its full term.
- Discount points: prepaid interest, with each point equal to 1% of the loan amount, paid to lower the rate.
- Lender credits: a credit toward closing costs in exchange for a higher rate.
- Origination charges: fees for processing and underwriting the loan.
The CFPB’s Loan Estimate explainer walks through the form. To compare two estimates line by line:
- On page 1, record the interest rate, monthly P&I, and the lock expiration.
- Still on page 1, check the “Estimated Cash to Close” figure.
- On page 2, Section A shows origination charges and any points. Compare the totals, not just the rate.
- Find any credits in Section J, and confirm the lock period behind each quote matches.
- On page 3, compare the APR and the “Total Interest Percentage” in the comparisons box.
The tradeoff to understand is that lender credits can reduce or erase your upfront costs. I call these no-out-of-pocket closing options: you accept a slightly higher rate and pay little to nothing out of pocket at closing. That’s sensible when cash is tight or you expect to move or refinance soon, and costly if you keep the loan for decades.
Total Cost of Ownership Worksheet: One Rate, Three Localities
A rate becomes a payment only after taxes, insurance, and mortgage insurance are added. The worksheet below holds the rate constant at 6.25% on a $400,000 purchase with 5% down ($380,000 loan, 95% LTV, 30-year fixed). P&I is $380 × 6.1572 = $2,339.74 in every locality.
Tax and insurance inputs below are assumptions I chose to show the mechanics, not quotes. Before you rely on them, pull the current rate from the official source for your property: Fairfax County, VA real estate tax, Hillsborough County, FL Property Appraiser, and Wake County, NC Tax Administration. I was unable to confirm today’s published rates for these pages, so each figure should be checked against its page and dated before use.
- Northern Virginia example: assumed 1.00% effective tax ($4,000/yr, $333.33/mo), insurance $150/mo, PMI $190/mo. Total: $3,013.07.
- Tampa-area Florida example: assumed 1.50% ($6,000/yr, $500.00/mo), insurance $400/mo, PMI $190/mo. Total: $3,429.74.
- Raleigh-area North Carolina example: assumed 0.70% ($2,800/yr, $233.33/mo), insurance $175/mo, PMI $190/mo. Total: $2,938.07.
The identical rate produces a $491.67 monthly spread between the first and last of these examples. Neither payment is more “good” in the abstract; what’s good is the one that fits your budget in the place you’re buying.
PMI math at 95% LTV
PMI here is an illustration, not a quote: 0.60% annual on $380,000 is $2,280 a year, or $190 a month. The CFPB mortgage resources explain the Homeowners Protection Act rules: you can request removal at 80% of the original value, and PMI terminates automatically at 78% if you’re current.
- 80% of $400,000 is a $320,000 balance. At 6.25% with the payment above, scheduled payments get you there at roughly month 120.
- 78% is a $312,000 balance, reached around month 132.
- If the home’s value rises, the same $380,000 balance equals 80% LTV at a $475,000 value ($380,000 ÷ 0.80), which can shorten the timeline with a new appraisal.
- At a flat $190 a month, 120 months of PMI totals about $22,800.
Comparison Table: Rate Scenarios Across Programs and Points
Illustrative figures only. These rates and APRs are placeholders to demonstrate the comparison, not quotes or market data. Payments use the standard formula on a $400,000 loan. The five-year column is P&I paid over 60 months plus any points, and it excludes mortgage insurance and funding fees. It’s cash paid, not net cost, since part of every payment is principal.
| Program | Term | Example rate | Approx. APR | Points / credits | Est. monthly P&I | 5-year P&I + points |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Conventional | 30-year | 6.25% | 6.31% | None | $2,462.87 | $147,772 |
| Conventional | 30-year | 6.00% | 6.22% | 1.5 points ($6,000) | $2,398.20 | $149,892 |
| Conventional | 15-year | 5.50% | 5.55% | None | $3,268.32 | $196,099 |
| FHA | 30-year | 5.875% | 6.6% (includes MIP) | None | $2,366.12 | $141,967 |
| VA | 30-year | 5.75% | 5.95% (includes funding fee) | None | $2,334.28 | $140,057 |
Breakeven is points cost divided by monthly savings. Using the first two rows, $6,000 ÷ $64.67 is about 93 months, or roughly 7.7 years. If you’ll sell or refinance before that, the no-points quote wins, as the five-year column shows: it is $2,120 cheaper at that mark.
Broker channel versus single-lender retail
| Factor | Independent broker | Single-lender retail shop |
|---|---|---|
| Products shown | Access to hundreds of wholesale lenders | One company’s own shelf |
| Side-by-side pricing | Built into the process | Requires you to gather other quotes |
| Rate/fee structure | Varies by lender selected | Set by a single company |
| Specialty programs | Can route to the lender suited to the file | Limited to what that company offers |
I won’t compare named companies’ advertised rates, because those change constantly and aren’t comparable without matching profiles. Either channel can produce a competitive quote, which is why you should test both.
How to Shop Your Rate Without Hurting Your Credit
Rate shopping doesn’t always damage credit. Scoring models generally treat multiple mortgage inquiries made within a short period as a single inquiry, because the borrower is shopping for one loan. The length of that window depends on the scoring model, and commonly cited figures range from 14 to 45 days. Confirm the current window in CFPB materials or with the scoring-model publisher, and keep all your quotes inside the shortest window to be safe.
A process that keeps your options open:
- Start with a soft-pull pre-approval so you see real pricing first. A no hard inquiry mortgage pre approval gives you a working number without any scoring impact.
- Request Loan Estimates from each source on the same day, so market movement doesn’t skew the comparison.
- Match the lock period and the points on every quote, or you’ll be comparing different products.
- Ask each source how long the lock lasts, what an extension costs, and whether a float-down is available if rates fall.
- Compare totals using the line-by-line method in the Loan Estimate section above.
As an independent broker, I compare across hundreds of wholesale lenders instead of showing you one company’s shelf. A mortgage pre approval without hard pull is available as a starting point, and from there it’s your choice whether to move forward. The goal is to compare your options, not to pressure a decision. If you’re buying in South Carolina, note that I operate there as a broker only.
Mortgage Rate FAQ: 10 Questions People Actually Ask
What is a good mortgage rate right now?
A good rate is at or below the current market average for your loan type and profile. As of the latest weekly release, the Freddie Mac PMMS at freddiemac.com/pmms publishes that average. Compare your quote to it, then adjust for your credit score, down payment, and points.
What is a good rate for a 15-year vs. 30-year loan?
Each term has its own benchmark, and 15-year rates are typically lower than 30-year rates. As of the latest PMMS release, both averages are listed separately. Judge a 15-year quote against the 15-year figure, not the 30-year one, and weigh the much higher monthly payment.
What credit score gets the lowest rates?
The highest score tiers receive the lowest pricing, and the breaks occur at set score bands, with top-tier pricing generally reserved for scores in the upper 700s and above. Exact thresholds depend on loan type and LTV, so request a soft-pull quote to see where your score places you.
Is a lower rate always cheaper?
No. A lower rate can cost more if it requires discount points you won’t recoup. In the example above, a 6.00% quote with 1.5 points on $400,000 doesn’t break even until about month 93. Compare total cost over the time you’ll hold the loan.
What is the difference between rate and APR?
The interest rate sets your payment, while APR adds certain finance charges, such as points and some fees, into a yearly cost. APR doesn’t include property taxes or homeowners insurance. Use it to compare loans with similar structures, and use total cost for the final decision.
How many points should I pay?
Pay points only if you’ll keep the loan past the breakeven point, which equals points cost divided by monthly savings. At $6,000 paid and $64.67 saved monthly, that is about 93 months. If you may sell or refinance sooner, skip points or consider lender credits.
How often do rates change?
Market rates can change daily, and lenders may reprice more than once in a day. The Freddie Mac PMMS is published weekly, so it’s a trend benchmark rather than a live quote. Once you lock, your rate is held for the lock period stated on your Loan Estimate.
What is a good rate for an FHA or VA loan?
Judge FHA and VA quotes against current market averages and against each other, and include insurance or funding fees. These programs can price below conventional, but mortgage insurance premiums and VA funding fees change the real cost. Check current HUD and VA.gov figures, and compare APR and monthly payment.
Can I get a rate quote without a hard credit pull?
Yes. A soft credit pull mortgage pre-approval shows personalized pricing without a hard inquiry on your report. It’s an estimate based on the information you provide, and a hard pull is typically needed later for final underwriting. It lets you compare options first.
Should I wait for rates to fall before buying?
Nobody can reliably predict rate movements, so waiting is a gamble in both directions. If you find a home you can afford at today’s payment, you can often refinance if rates fall, though refinancing has its own costs. Run the numbers on both scenarios before deciding.
The Test That Defines a Good Rate
A good rate passes two checks: it compares well against the PMMS benchmark for your loan type and profile, and it holds up on total cost once points, fees, taxes, insurance, and mortgage insurance are counted. If a quote fails either check, keep shopping. If it passes both, you have your answer.
Your dream home is within reach: discover how much you could save with personalized mortgage rates tailored to your unique situation. Securely pre-qualify in minutes with no impact to your credit score and compare competitive offers from trusted lenders who are ready to help you save. A soft-pull pre-approval with Duane Buziak at Shop Mortgage Rates by Duane Buziak puts those options side by side before you commit to one.
Next, learn how to read the document that makes these comparisons possible in How to Read a Loan Estimate Line by Line.

